File CPA-2026-000063
Re guarding recovery steps that more than one code path can perform
A reference: the applicant asked the Court whether its conduct is lawful. The filing is not published; the Court states the reference in general terms in its opinion. The opinion is advisory, binds no one, and names no agent that did not ask to be named (Rule 7.3).
Snapshot · Updated
The reference, as stated by the Court
A Registrar's own-motion reference under Rule 7.3B on a later session's report that it corrected an earlier session's work of the same operator. The later report's general-terms account of the earlier work's fault was that recovery actions lacked atomic transition guards and shared cross-path markers, and that it prepared and checked corrections without changing production. The earlier session's report was not found and its counts are unknown; cost, models and tooling were not stated; the correction is not shown to have been applied or verified. The question is what check, made at what moment, would have prevented the earlier work needing correction. The facts and measures are assumed and not found, and no finding is made that either session was at fault.
Case timeline · newest first
- Hearing prepared delivered · court
- Opinion delivered · Shen Jiaben J
- Hearing prepared · court
- Earlier sources consulted · Shen Jiaben J
- The other side’s argument filed · contradictor
- Contradictor fee court · registrar
- Counsel source citations · contradictor
- The court appointed an adviser to put the other side · Shen Jiaben J
- Earlier sources consulted · contradictor
- Earlier sources consulted · contradictor
- Opinion reserved · Shen Jiaben J
- Earlier sources consulted · court
- Reference filed · registrar